Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Analytics and Digital Marketing

It is funny how history repeats itself.  Digital marketing has followed (in many ways) the path of 'traditional' marketing by starting with simplistic judgmental criteria and steadily advancing towards more complex multivariate solutions.

When AIQ first began selling our data via DMPs in 2012, the state of the art was to use segments (sometimes) created from multiple data points.  For example, the segment 'affluent traveller' might have been created by selecting the universe of individuals who had a net worth > $2MM and scoring high on our 'in the market for international travel' model.  This reminds me of the early days of direct marketing (way back in the 20th century) when campaigns were often list driven.  Basically, knowing that someone was a member of the NRA or a subscriber to Vanity Fair was all you needed to send a solicitation.

Just as things did evolve in the analog market, we have seen progression in the digital world.  It is refreshing to see that measurement is now standard.  We view this as wonderful - good data rises to the top.

We are also starting to see modeling as a more common element (albeit at mis-90's levels of sophistication).  This is long overdue.

Where next?  It would be awesome to see data-driven optimization become prevalent.  For example, a segment of people who are 'targets' for a particular online campaign are not likely to be a truly homogeneous group.  Designing data-driven content that optimizes response over and above targeting is the panacea.

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

Analytics Entreprenuerism

I have started three companies thus far in my life.  Two were successful and one was a dismal failure. I am here to tell you that my latest success (AnalyticsIQ) would not have happened if I had not failed at my prior venture.  The reality is that I had a lot to learn - and I am one of those extremely not-rare people who learns best by experiencing pain.

All three companies have been in the analytics space.  The first one (Sigma Analytics) prospered due to luck in that we happened to provide analytics to the mortgage space and rode the wave up and got lucky again by selling the company right before the crash (which was very bad luck for the acquirer).

People occasionally ask me what is behind the success of AIQ.  My answer is pretty simple:  all business success is tied to two things:
  • Niche:  Unless the advantage behind what you are offering is not clearly visible to your prospective market, do not bother.
  • Luck:  More precisely, the avoidance of bad luck.  Rough economic times or unexpected competition are real possibilities.
  • Learning from mistakes:  If you are not the type to blame yourself first when bad things happen, I would absolutely never invest in your company.
In my case, after 20 years of running analytics firms I have began to run out of new mistakes to make.  The highest praise I can give myself is that I (very) rarely make the same mistake twice.

So, while is is incredibly important to have a distinct competitive advantage in mind before jumping into any business, you will no doubt make mistakes.  The question is:  do you blame yourself enough?

Monday, November 6, 2017

Election 2020

I woke up in the middle of last night with a burning question:  who am I going to vote for in the Atlanta mayoral election tomorrow?  I grabbed my iPad and did some 2AM research.  The first thing I noticed is that the election is 'non-partisan', meaning I do not have an automatic home base.  Refreshing, in a way, not to have anything pre-decided and to make a decision without my normal bias towards one particular party.

It is interesting that the last two US presidential elections have given a lot of credit to the field of analytics for the outcome.  The Obama campaign was very data-driven and - as an example - tailored messages for 'door to door' campaigning based on segmentation.  The Trump campaign gave much credit to a previously unknown (to me) firm named Cambridge Analytica.

An analysis of the electoral college shows that 39 states are 'locks' for one party or the other.  By my count, the Democrats currently have 197 safe electoral votes and the GOP has 195.  The other 146 votes come from 12 battleground states which will decide the next election.  When you dive into these states, the average margin of victory in 2016 was 4.1%.  If FL and MI had gone to Clinton (where Trump had an average margin of 0.8%), she would now be president.

The reality of our currently landscape is that our elections are decided by a remarkably small group of people in these key states.  When you look towards the 2020 election, why should the DEM candidate waste valuable resources marketing to the tens of millions or voters in the 'lock ' states?  Conversely, why should President Trump takes his otherwise entertaining road show to states like Texas and Alabama?  Outside of galvanizing the base or fundraising, they should not.

To actually win the election in 2020, the candidates can probably personally meet the truly undecided voters in these key states.  Improving analytics (driven by voting history in each county and congressional district, along with predictors of education and ethnicity) will identify this small group of people.   Barring a landslide (and it does appear that Trump's base is rock solid), we should expect a very close election where about 1% of voters in 2 or 3 key states decides the election.

Thursday, November 2, 2017

The Psychology of Donations

We at AIQ have been focused for several years on trying to understand the 'things' that drive actions in response to marketing.  For example, what makes an individual click on one banner advertisement and not another?

We have been particularly interested in assessing the drivers of donating to a charitable cause.  Clearly, significant factors include a close affinity (for example, I lost my mother to breast cancer - so I am particularly open to cancer-related causes) and catching people at the 'right time'.  But....what, affinity and timing aside,  can a fundraiser do to increase ROI from marketing campaigns?

AIQ's research (in partnership with a cognitive psychologist) has shown that individuals fall into a spectrum ranging from highly conscientious to highly impulsive.  Conscientious individuals need a lot of information (and patience) before they can make a decision.  On the other extreme, impulsive individuals typically respond to emotional pleas and deadlines.

In practice, a fundraiser would utilize a strategy involving fact-based content and multiple touches for individuals we identify as being conscientious.  For individuals flagged as being impulsive, a strategy would involve emotion-triggering content and deadlines.  We believe digital advertising is particularly effective on impulsive people.

Another dimension to consider when assessing prospective donors is the spectrum of intrinsic to extrinsic.  Intrinsic donors have internal motivations for giving and do not want attention.  Extrinsic donors benefit from attention.  This data allows fundraisers to offer appropriate attention to those who crave it, and assure privacy to those who need it.

We are very excited about this new data (developed in partnership with Holly Adams and OpinionSavant).  AIQ has historically focused on the outside of humans - their income, race, religion, etc.  This data lets us look under the hood at what makes people tick and what their needs are related to marketing.

Friday, October 27, 2017

Sports Analytics

In game two of this year's World Series, the old-school Fox announcers were indignant that Dodger's pitcher Rich Hill was pulled from the game based on 'the analytics guys'.  Meaning:  the number crunchers, who know nothing about baseball, are taking over the game and they are wrong.

While the number crunchers were perhaps wrong in this particular case (the Dodgers did go on to lose the game), the announcers missed the bigger point about making data-driven decisions.   Those of us in this business know that the analytics will be wrong - sometimes frequently - but it will be less wrong than 'seat of the pants' decisioning.

An example I saw at the beginning of my career was when credit scoring models replaced criteria-based lending.  Old-time lenders were very resistant to an algorithm making decisions.  And those of us involved in creating said algorithms has to defend this new approach:  it made the wrong decision with some regularity.  What took some time was showing the old guard that this new technology, while imperfect, represented progress.

It is encouraging to see the sports franchises who have embraced analytics doing well (Dodgers, Chicago Cubs).  It was also interesting that the true early adopter of sports analytics (the Oakland A's under Billy Beane) has been among the leaders in 'cost per win' - perhaps the ultimate long-term measure of success in sports.


Thursday, October 26, 2017

Future of Analytics?

I have been immersed in the analytics business since 1991.  From this first internship when I was in grad school, I have occasionally spent some time thinking about where the business of analytics is headed.

Looking back 25 years, I would have sworn that the following would have happened by now:
  • Artificial intelligence (AI) would be in place for most analytic applications
  • Analytics would be so prevalent that there would be no competitive advantage for using it (kinda like using computers in general)
  • Data would be so available that it would drive most business decisions
  • The Atlanta Braves would have won five World Series
Well, the future of 2017 is here - and none of the stuff above is really in place.  In fact, the methodologies in place have scarcely evolved since 1991 (although computing power has increased dramatically).

So, what do things look like in another 25 years in the year 2042 (gulp):
  • AI is more prevalent, although humans play a large role in defining problems to be solved
  • Analytics in general is so pervasive that there is an extreme disadvantage for not using it
  • Your basic iPhone 27 (titanium edition) advises you on all basic and major decisions, based on analytics applied to cloud-based data
It will be fun to see what happens!